Writing : Does the paper have an explicit why question, writing homework help

Rubric for evaluation (out of 7 points)

1.  Does the paper have an explicit why question? (1 out of 7)

Do you find the why question interesting, powerful, important, engaging?  Explain why you find it interesting etc (or what you don’t find compelling and why).  Do you think it is an appropriate why question for the subject being discussed?  Is it too broad a question or too narrow a question?  (or is it too general a question or too specific a question?)

  [Comment on the appropriateness of the why question.] 

2.  Is there an answer to the why question?  (1 out of 7)

Is the answer interesting, powerful, important, engaging?  Does the answer fit with the question?  (Is the answer too specific or too general?).  Does the answer make sense?

[Comment on the answer to the why question.]

3.  Does the paper (as is) give a persuasive sense of how your answer is a good/the best answer to the why question? (1 out of 7)

Is evidence presented in concrete, analytical ways?  [The writer may need to provide some historical background to the issue, but is the body of the essay all historical background, with little or no concrete evidence?]   Does the evidence support the argument?  Does the evidence also support other arguments? 

[Comment on the fit of the evidence and the argument.]

Is the evidence presented the best evidence to support the argument?  (Does it present a “smoking gun”—conclusive evidence needed to make the author’s argument?)

[Comment generally on how well or how poorly the evidence and the answer to the why question go together.]

4.  Is the paper four full pages, with specified margins and font? (1 out of 7)

The paper, with a minimum of four pages.  The research question and argument must be laid out clearly and the draft should give a sense of how you will prove your argument.   Is this real, potentially usable text or is the writer filling in space to get to four full pages? 

[Comment on whether you think the writer is well along on the paper or whether the writer really has to get down to work.] 

5.  Does the paper show signs of using primary sources and secondary sources (has actual research been done)? (1 out of 7)

  Does the writer actually mention or cite his/her sources?

[Comment on whether you think the writer has done enough research and if not enough, what you think the writer has to do.]

6.  Realizing this is a draft, is the paper reasonably well organized and written? (1 out of 7; 14 out of 100) 

Is it written in a reasonably logical way?    Did the writer take care in writing—not too many typos, spelling mistakes, grammatical errors? 

[Comment on clarity of expression, organization, style, and other presentational aspects of the draft/]

7.  General comments on the draft.  (1 out of 7)

  Is this a good paper so far?

  What needs to be done for the final version?  Where does it need work?

  What needs to be done to improve the paper? 


peer_review_paper.docx

Answers

Related Questions

Interpersonal Communications COMM285...

Communication Trends In The Workplace Running Head: Assignment 1:Trends in the Workplace Assignment 1:Trends in the Workplace HRM 500 HR...

1. Discuss why those in the human resource develop...

1. Discuss why those in the human resource development positions are in a prime position to facilitate the change process. How can they develop employ...

Established in 1977, Krona Community Hospital is a...

Established in 1977, Krona Community Hospital is a 60-bed, acute care hospital located in the heart of Banconota County. With a staff of nearly 100 ph...

COMM285 Interpersonal Communications ESSAY...

Impact Of The Computer On Communication In BusinessThe Impact of Computers in Business by Chris Joseph, Demand Media Computers have made a major impac...

A) How does media create meanings about gender?...

A) How does media create meanings about gender? B) Provide examples of how this is manifested in our everyday lives. C) Provide a link to a commerci...

COMM285 Interpersonal Communications...

This option allows you to choose from a selection of several chapters of books by scholar Deborah Tannen that are available electronically from the AP...

1. Wayne Baker (Shafritz Sub Ch 33 “The Network...

Here are the following instructions below:1. Wayne Baker (Shafritz Sub Ch 33 “The Network Organization in Theory and Practice”) discusses the netw...

A) Mass Communication sets or perpetuates some gen...

· Review the Learning Resources attached files before answering the week 6 discussion. Respond to the following prompts by providing examples of eac...

Describe the differences between needs identificat...

From the end of Chapter 6, complete the following questions out of the section titled “Questions for Review and Discussion.” Each question should...

Public Speaking COMM200...

Why public speaking course is important to college students? College studies are the main key for social mobilization and for sound professional devel...

PHIL200 Introduction to Ethics...

PHIL200 Introduction to Ethics 1.Do you approve of Kierkegaard’s father’s teaching technique? Explain. Are there similarities between his techniqu...

1. Write a one...

Write a four to five (4-5) page paper in which you:1.      Write a one-page summary of the policy (Healthcare Reform), including the purpose, the...

PHIL200 Introduction to Ethics Assignment...

PHIL200 Introduction to Ethics Assignment Ethics is the study of the nature of moral virtues and evaluates human actions. Ethics come from agreements...

Cover letters are recommended, and in some instanc...

Cover letters are recommended, and in some instances required, for job applications. If you want to stand out from other candidates, you will want to...

The Capstone Paper is the culmination of the Milit...

The Capstone Paper is the culmination of the Military Studies Program. Through it the student should  demonstrate mastery of the learning outcomes of...

"Tax incentives to new or existing business seldom...

Read and Write a discussion question from the reading . CH2 RUBIN. PDFThere is an example from the this chapter. 2 paragraphAdd page number next to th...

European integration has been marked by a gradual...

European integration has been marked by a gradual deepening of its political system – analyze the decisive steps (e.g. treaties) on this way towards...

Week 3 Assignment: Essay...

Week 3 Assignment: Essay – Developing a DemocracyInstructions Many countries have gone through various ways of governing-by one, by a group, or by...

PHIL110 Critical Thinking Essay...

PHL 1010, Critical Thinking Unit VI EssayPHIL110 Critical Thinking Essay Provide an example from your own experience where you acted in accordance wit...

PHIL110 Critical Thinking...

Attributes of a Critical Thinker and Their Application in University Learning PHIL110 Critical Thinking Without developing your critical thinking self...

This section reviews elections in the U.S., the va...

This section reviews elections in the U.S., the various branches of government and their roles and interactions.  Section includes a research writin...

1...

1- Rubin chapter 1 page 9 ( pdf reading) There is a certain amount of agreement and coordination that needs to be found between the different actors...

"The Israeli...

“The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict” Please respond to the following:  For thousands of years, up to the 20th century, the land of Palestine was...

What Would You Do? Will You Support the Budget...

What Would You Do? Will You Support the Budget Plan Proposed By Congress?INSTRUCTIONS: In this activity, you assume the role of the President who has...

If you didn't find the right answer

Ask Your Questions, We'll notify you once someone answers it